[EDIT: Please note that the title to this post is a question. And that I don't pretend to have an answer. And, yes, while I think Keira looks thin - or at least, in many images - I don't know definitively she needs to put on weight to be 100% healthy. But I would take that bet, sure I would]
Keira Knightly has apparently told Elle magazine she's toying with the notion of quitting acting alltogether. Her reason? She's being used as a role model by pro-anorexia websites.
Easiest way to sort that, Keira? Bulk up a little. Not only will that stop you being a role model for those suffering from mental illness, you might even become a role model for those trying to escape those shackles.
I can hear the complaints now: she's naturally thin, she's supposed to be like that.
Right. She might be naturally thin, but even for her natural state, she's small. Ask your GP, just conversationally, what the chances are that Keira could be a healthy weight. They'll laugh at the question.
[EDIT: The anonymous comment below suggested the Elle article would answer my questions. It doesn't, really. It gives Keira plenty of space to make her case, and that's only right and she does a pretty good job. But there's not even any suggestion, let alone evidence, that she's a healthy weight. And that means now, not just in the infamous skin-and-bone bikini pictures. Why not all read the article for yourself - page one, two, three - thanks to 'Dangermouse']
I'm frightened that, in fact, Keira simply wants to starve herself in peace. She's getting too many mixed messages, and without fame, and with the little extra-dash of self loathing this stand-down could provide, there's every chance she could clear out those people trying to help her get healthier and she'd pretty soon be in a teeny little grave.
Find me one single medical professional that will back up Keira's claims she's healthy and I'll find you a dictionary to revise your definitions of medical and professional.
Personally, I'd like her to quit acting. Yes, because she's actually being quite a good role model for anorexics - and this whole heap of nonsense is only furthering that - but also because, frankly, she's not much cop.